The Solo Songs Paul McCartney Isn’t Playing in Concert


Paul
McCartney

has
written
or
co-written
32
chart-topping
singles
on
Billboard’s
Hot
100
–
including
seven
as
a
solo
act
and
with

Wings
.
His
24
total
No.
1
songs
in
the
U.K.
are
more
than
any
other
artist.

He
plays
those
a
lot.
In
many
cases,
the
best-known
singles
from
his
catalog
became
the
most
performed
songs
in
concert
–
but
not
always.
For
every
blockbuster
like “Band
on
the
Run,” “My
Love”
and “Maybe
I’m
Amazed,”
there
are
surprising
examples
of
McCartney
regularly
digging
deeper
into
his
solo
material.

The
least-played
songs
weren’t
necessarily
the
worst,
either.
Some
albums
arrived
when
McCartney
was
off
the
road,
so
they
never
found
their
way
to
the
stage.


READ
MORE:


Top
40
Paul
McCartney ’70s
Songs

For
instance,
McCartney
didn’t
tour
between
1980,
the
same
year
former
bandmate

John
Lennon

was
murdered,
and
his
Tripping
the
Live
Fantastic
Tour
in
support
of


Flowers
in
the
Dirt

in
1989-90.
During
that
quiet
era,
McCartney
released
1982’s


Tug
of
War
,
1983’s


Pipes
of
Peace
,
1984’s


Give
My
Regards
to
Broadstreet

and
1986’s


Press
to
Play
.

A
few
tracks
from

Tug
of
War

and

Press
to
Play

later
filtered
into
McCartney’s
set
lists.
But
he
has
yet
to
return
to

Pipes
of
Peace

or

Give
My
Regards
to
Broadstreet
,
even
though
they
were
home
to
the
international
Top
10
hits “Say,
Say,
Say”
and “No
More
Lonely
Nights,”
respectively.

Other
songs
have
been
played
literally
hundreds
of
times
–
in
particular
when
you
combine
performances
by
McCartney
as
a
solo
act
and
performances
with
his ’70s-era
band
Wings.
Using
data
from

setlist.fm
,
we’ve
crunched
the
numbers
to
determine
the
most
and
least
played
song
live
from
every
Paul
McCartney
album.


Album:


McCartney
III

(2020)


Most
played:
“Women
and
Wives”
(47)

Least
played:
“Slidin'”
(1)

Deep
into
pandemic-era
quarantines,
McCartney
decided
to
complete
the
third
installment
in
a
series
of
solo
recordings
that
already
included
1970’s


McCartney

and
1980’s


McCartney
II
.
Inspiration
came
from
smaller
things
in
that
quiet,
isolated
time:
The
bluesy “Women
and
Wives”
arrived
while
McCartney
was
reading
a
book
on
the
Louisiana
legend
Lead
Belly.
McCartney
sang
the
original
with
a
surprisingly
hard,
flatter
tone
while
playing
a
bass
that
belonged
to
early

Elvis
Presley

band
member
Bill
Black. “Slidin'”
has
roots
in
a
jam
session
that
grew
out
of
a
soundcheck
with
his
regular
band
in
Dusseldorf,
Germany
–
and
it
sounds
just
like
that.
McCartney
made
an
initial
pass
at
the
song
during
sessions
for
2018’s


Egypt
Station
.

 


Album:


Egypt
Station

(2018)


Most
played:
“Come
On
to
Me”
(107)

Least
played:
“Happy
With
You”
(1)

These
two
songs
could
not
be
more
different.
The
thrice-married
McCartney
imagines
himself
as
a
youthful
pickup
artist
on
the
frankly
perfunctory
rocker “Come
On
to
Me,”
originally
released
as
a
advance
double-A
side
single
with
the

far,
far
superior
“I
Don’t
Know.” “Happy
With
You,”
though
undoubtedly
slight,
is
a
better
song,
too.
Nobody
conveys
the
comforts
of
everyday
contentment
quite
like
Paul
McCartney.

 


Album:


New

(2013)


Most
played:
“Queenie
Eye”
(216)

Least
played:
“Appreciate”
(1)

Well
deserved,
since “Queenie
Eye”
was
the
best
song
on


New
.
Its
ruminative
orchestral
opening,
fizzy
word
play,
nervy
grooves
and
processed
vocal
point
like
a
streaking
arrow
back
to
his
late ’60s
successes
with

George
Martin

and
the
rest
of
the

Beatles
.
In
a
sign
of
just
how
confident
this
McCartney
album
is,
there’s
even
a
perfectly
landed
false
ending.
He
then
does
what
every
Beatles
trope
says
he
should
do:
Start
all
over
again,
with
a
swirling
chorus
of
vocals,
a
banging
piano
and
a
second
sudden
stop.
Elsewhere, “Appreciate”
works
as
a
preview
of
the
very
modern
experiments
to
come
on
2020’s


McCartney
III
.

 


Album:


Memory
Almost
Full

(2007)


Most
played:
“Dance
Tonight”
(226)

Least
played:
“Nod
Your
Head”
(4)

Ironically,
the
last
song
written
for
McCartney’s
deeply
underrated


Memory
Almost
Full

became
its
most
played.
Nominated
for
a
Grammy, “Dance
Tonight”
was
a
personal
moment
inspired
by
the
exuberance
of
his
young
daughter.
McCartney
played
every
instrument.
Described
as
a “little
stompy
rocker,” “Nod
Your
Head”
served
as
a
more
light-hearted
album-closer
after
a
five
song-medley
(from “Vintage
Clothes”
to “The
End
of
the
End”)
in
which
McCartney
examines
a
life’s
arc. “We
thought
we
couldn’t
leave
everyone
going, ‘Oh
God,
I’m
not
going
to
listen
to
that
again,'”
McCartney

later
joked
.

 


Album:


Chaos
and
Creation
in
the
Backyard

(2005)


Most
played:
“Follow
Me”
(44)

Least
played:
“At
the
Mercy,” “Riding
to
Vanity
Fair”
and “Too
Much
Rain”
(1)

A
complete
return
to
form,


Chaos
and
Creation
in
the
Backyard

wasn’t
just
one
of
the
best
Paul
McCartney
albums
in
ages.
It’s
one
of
the
best
ever.
New
producer
Nigel
Godrich
helped
McCartney
get
there
by
convincing
him
to
scrap
almost
all
of
the
early
band-based
versions
of
these
songs
in
favor
of
a
more
settled
solo
approach.
Godrich’s
fingerprints
are
everywhere,
from
making
McCartney
slow
down
on “Riding
to
Vanity
Fair”
to
the
dark
forces
at
work
in “At
the
Mercy”
and “Too
Much
Rain.” “Follow
Me,”
with
its
churchy “Let
It
Be”-type
overtones,
was
one
of
the
few
early
takes
that
survived.
It
was
only
played
four
more
times
than
the
Top
20
U.K.
single “Fine
Line”
and
the “Blackbird”-esque “Jenny
Wren.”

 


Album:


Driving
Rain

(2001)


Most
played:
“Your
Loving
Flame”
(94)

Least
played:
“From
a
Lover
to
a
Friend”
(1)



Driving
Rain

made
the
Top
30
in
the
U.S.,
but
finished
at
a
paltry
No.
46
in
McCartney’s
native
U.K. “From
a
Lover
to
a
Friend”
was
its
highest
charting
single,
a
step
back
at
No.
45
in
the
U.K.
But
this
also
marked
the
debut
of
guitarist
Rusty
Anderson
and
drummer
Abe
Laboriel
Jr.,
two
members
of
McCartney’s

longest-standing
band
. “Your
Loving
Flame,”
a
rather
generic
love
song
for
McCartney’s
new
wife,
was
played
just
two
more
times
than
runner-up “Lonely
Road.”
(Thankfully,
he
only
performed
the
boring,
surprisingly
jingoistic “Freedom”
some
55
times.) “From
a
Lover
to
a
Friend,”
on
the
other
hand,
boasts
an
fascinatingly
irregular
meter
that
McCartney
chose
to
keep
from
his
original
demo.

 


Album:


Flaming
Pie

(1997)


Most
played:
“Flaming
Pie”
(115)

Least
played:
“Beautiful
Night,” “The
World
Tonight”
and “Somedays”
(1)

After
spending
much
of
the
mid-’90s
deep
in
the
Beatles
archives
for
the


Anthology

series,
McCartney
returned
with
an
album
dotted
with
references
to
the
old
days.
The
title
of


Flaming
Pie

was
lifted
from
an
old
John
Lennon
quote.
(Someone
asked
about
the
band
name. “It
came
in
a
vision
–
a
man
appeared
on
a
flaming
pie
and
said
unto
them, ‘From
this
day
on
you
are
Beatles
with
an
A,'”
Lennon
told


Mersey
Beat

in
1961.) “Beautiful
Night”
featured

Ringo
Starr

and
orchestration
by
George
Martin
and
joined
McCartney’s
nervy
rocker “The
World
Tonight”
in
the
U.K.
Top
30.
Martin
scored “Somedays,”
too.

 


Album:


On
the
Ground

(1993)


Most
played:
“Hope
of
Deliverance”
(101)

Least
played:
“Cosmically
Conscious”
(1)

The
best
songs
from


On
the
Ground

(“Mistress
and
Maid,” “The
Lovers
That
Never
Were”)
featured
collaborative
songwriting
with
turn-of-the-’90s
songwriting
partner

Elvis
Costello
.
Those
were
not
the
songs
that
were
released
as
singles.
U.K.
fans
dutifully
sent
the
slight “Hope
of
Deliverance”
into
the
Top
20
but
the
single
couldn’t
get
past
No.
83
on
the
Billboard
chart.
That
was
McCartney’s
best
finish
during
this
cycle
of
singles. “Cosmically
Conscious”
began
life
as
a
raucous
coda
to
the
album-closing “C’mon
People”
before
McCartney
resurrected
it
during
2009’s
Change
Begins
Within
benefit
concert
at
Radio
City
Music
Hall.

 


Album:


Flowers
in
the
Dirt

(1989)


Most
played:
“My
Brave
Face”
(120)

Least
played:
“How
Many
People”
and “Distractions”
(2)

Costello
brought
a
smart
sense
of
history
to
his
first
songwriting
sessions
with
McCartney. “My
Brave
Face”
helped
the
Beatles
star
channel
his
former
pop
self,
right
down
to
the
vintage
bass.
As
with
those
old
records,
McCartney
and
Costello
raced
through
recording “My
Brave
Face”
in
just
two
days. “How
Many
People,”
with
its
somewhat
questionable
reggae
vibe,
quite
obviously
emerged
from
sessions
with
people
not
named
Elvis
Costello.
On
the
other
hand, “Distractions”
features
an
intriguing
arrangement
from
longtime

Prince

collaborator
Clare
Fischer.

 


Album:


Press
to
Play

(1986)


Most
played:
“Only
Love
Remains”
(2)

Least
played:
“Stranglehold”
(1)

The
Hugh
Padgham-produced

Press
to
Play

peaked
at
a
solo
worst
No.
30
in
the
U.S.,
becoming
his
first
ever
not
to
at
least
reach
gold
certification.
McCartney’s
first
single,
the
annoyingly
mechanized “Press,”
just
missed
the
Billboard
Top
20
–
and
it
was
all
downhill
from
there. “Only
Love
Remains”
didn’t
reach
the
Billboard
chart
at
all,
though
it
became
this
LP’s
second
U.K.
Top
40
single
after “Press.” “Stranglehold”
was
the
only
other
charting
single
in
the
U.S.,
and
it
stalled
at
No.
81.
Still,
the
song
represented
the
first
frail
flowering
of
a
creative
rebound,
as
McCartney
sets
a
smart
little
reed-honking
groove
then
barks
out
the
lyrics
with
a
whiskey-shot
of
vigor.
He’d
soon
began
a
creative
rebound
with
Costello.

 


Album:


Tug
of
War

(1982)


Most
played:
“Here
Today”
(475)

Least
played:
“Take
It
Away”
and “Dress
Me
Up
as
a
Robber”
(1)

The
tender,
deeply
personal “Here
Today”
closed
out
Side
1
of
the
first
album
McCartney
issued
after
his
childhood
friend
and
collaborator
John
Lennon
was
killed
by
a
deranged
fan.
The
loss
still
clearly
ran
deep:
McCartney
wouldn’t
begin
playing “Here
Today”
on
stage
until
2001. “Take
It
Away”
was
pitched
as
a
partial
Beatles
reunion,
with
Starr
on
drums
and
Martin
at
the
mixing
board.
But
this
patented
McCartney
pop
confection,
with
its
deceptively
intricate
bass,
feverish
horn
counterpoint
and
indecipherable
narrative,
really
speaks
more
to
the
band
that
followed: “Take
It
Away”
could
have
emerged
from
Wings
at
their
chart-topping
peak.
As
for “Dress
Me
Up
as
a
Robber,”
one
performance
seems
like
enough.

 


Album:


McCartney
II

(1980)


Most
played:
“Coming
Up”
(367
solo;
20
with
Wings)

Least
played:
“Temporary
Secretary”
(82
solo)

The
original
version
arrived
as
part
of
a
largely
improvised
solo
synth
experiment,
with
tinny
vocals
courtesy
of
a
vari-speed
tape
machine.
U.K.
fans
sent
this
take
to
No.
2,
while
American
disc
jockeys
turned
the
single
over
to
play
Wings’
B-side
version
from
their
final
concert.
Recalling
the
band’s
previous
success
with
an
update
of “Maybe
I’m
Amazed,”
Wings
produced
the
bigger
hit
as “Coming
Up
(Live
at
Glasgow)”
went
to
No.
1
in
the
U.S.
Meanwhile, “Temporary
Secretary”
finally
made
a

concert
debut

in
2016.
McCartney
said
he
returned
to
it
after
a
DJ
made
the
song
popular
in
dance
clubs
across
Europe.

 


Album:


Back
to
the
Egg

(1979)


Most
played:
“Spin
It
On”
(20
with
Wings,
1
solo);

Least
played:
“Rockestra
Theme”
(2
with
Wings)

Wings
was
still
touring
behind
this
LP
when
McCartney
got

busted
for
drugs

in
Japan.
He
ended
up
spending
nine
days
in
jail.
McCartney
then
returned
home,
completed

McCartney
II
,
and
Wings
never
issued
another
album.
Most
of
the
material
from


Back
to
the
Egg
,
including
the
funky
single “Arrow
Through
Me,”
was
played
20
times
during
the
final
concerts
by
Wings
–
except
for “Spin
It
On.”
McCartney
returned
to
it
once,
moving
the
B-side
to
the
Top
20
hit “Getting
Closer”
past
the
others. “Rockestra
Theme,”
a
Grammy-winning
supergroup
recording
featuring

Pete
Townshend
,

David
Gilmour
,

Ronnie
Lane
,

John
Bonham

and
others,
has
likely
remained
off
the
set
list
simply
because
of
its
massive
scale.

 


Album:


London
Town

(1978)


Most
played:
“Mull
of
Kintyre”
(21
with
Wings;
41
solo)

Least
played:
“I’ve
Had
Enough”
(20
with
Wings)

The
most
played
song
from
the


London
Town

sessions
–
and
the
era’s
best-selling
single
–
was
left
off
the
original
track
listing
for
reasons
that
are
difficult
to
fathom.
(Later
editions
rectified
the
problem.) “Mull
of
Kintyre”
was
written
with
Wings
bandmate

Denny
Laine

in
tribute
to
the
peninsula
in
western
Scotland
where
McCartney’s
farm
is
located,
and
recorded
in
a
converted
barn
on
the
property
with
the
local
Campbeltown
Pipers.
As
expected,
the
results
were
far,
far
more
popular
in
the
U.K.,
where “Mull
of
Kintyre”
held
the
No.
1
spot
for
nine
weeks
while
selling
more
than
two
million
copies.
The
single
didn’t
even
chart
in
America. “I’ve
Had
Enough,”
a
tough
little
Billboard
Top
40
rocker,
fared
much
better.

 


Album:


Wings
at
the
Speed
of
Sound

(1976)


Most
played:
“Let ‘Em
In”
(314
solo,
43
with
Wings)

Least
played:
“Cook
of
the
House”
(19
with
Wings)

McCartney
rushed
out


Wings
at
the
Speed
of
Sound

ahead
of
his
first
U.S.
tour
since
the
Beatles’

final
bow
in
1966
.
The
results
were
occasionally
feather
light,
as
with “Let ‘Em
In,”
but
also
irresistible:
The
LP
shot
to
the
top
of
the
charts
over
seven
non-consecutive
weeks
while
producing
consecutive
gold-selling
Top
5
singles.
(Some
of
those
found
knocking
at
the
front
door
were
real
friends
and
relatives
and
some
weren’t.
Ironically,
McCartney
later
married
Nancy
Shevell,
who
has
both
a “Sister
Susie”
and
a “Brother
Jon.”)
Unfortunately,
McCartney
gave
the
mic
over
to
everyone
else
during
this
head-scratchingly
democratic
era
–
and
that
included

Linda
McCartney

for
the
pretty
embarrassing “Cook
of
the
House.”

 


Album:


Venus
and
Mars

(1975)


Most
played:
“Letting
Go”
(203
solo,
67
with
Wings)

Least
played:
“Venus
and
Mars/Rock
Show”
(35
solo;
67
with
Wings)

“Letting
Go”
just
missed
the
Top
40
in
the
U.K.;
it
barely
crept
into
the
Billboard
Top
40.
Yet
McCartney
returns
to “Letting
Go”
more
than
any
other
track
from


Venus
and
Mars

–
even
the
No.
1
smash “Listen
to
What
the
Man
Said”
(78
solo,
68
with
Wings).
They
couldn’t
be
more
different:
McCartney
explored
that
narrow
space
between
love
and
obsession
in
the
strikingly
dark “Letting
Go,”
even
as
the
pop-perfect “Listen
What
the
Man
Said”
became
the
bigger
hit.
Meanwhile, “Venus
and
Mars/Rock
Show”
reflects
this
LP’s
settled
atmosphere.
McCartney
had
now
established
himself
away
from
the
Beatles,
so
there
was
suddenly
time
to
look
toward
the
stars. “Rock
Show”
then
provided
a
winking
travelogue
to
bring
fans
back
home.

 


Album:


Band
on
the
Run

(1973)


Most
played:
“Band
on
the
Run”
(712
solo,
87
with
Wings)

Least
played:
“Picasso’s
Last
Words
[Drink
to
Me]”
(1
solo)

No
surprise
here.
Can
Paul
McCartney
even
have
concert
without
the
thrillingly
episodic
title
song
from


Band
on
the
Run
? “Picasso’s
Last
Words
(Drink
to
Me)”
emerged
from
a
dinner
party
hosted
by
actor
Dustin
Hoffman
during
sessions
for
the
album.
In
a
friendly
challenge,
Hoffman
handed
him
a
copy
of

Time

magazine
and
asked
McCartney
to
write
a
song
using
a
random
article.
McCartney
found
a
quote
attributed
to
Picasso
from
just
before
he
died
–
and
started
singing
this
song’s
chorus.
Hoffman
could

only
exclaim
: ‘He’s
doing
it!
He’s
doing
it!
Come
and
listen!'”

 


Album:


Red
Rose
Speedway

(1973)


Most
played:
“My
Love”
(230
solo;
123
with
Wings)

Least
played:
“Big
Barn
Bed”
(8
solo)

Sure,
McCartney’s “My
Love”
lyrics
are
saccharine
(and
the
strings
even
more
so),
but
he
just
sells
it.
Then
Wings
guitarist
Henry
McCullough
steps
forward
to
complete “My
Love”
with
a
searing
solo
turn
that
he
had
to
fight
hard
to
include. “Big
Barn
Bed”
is
another
example,
and
perhaps
the
best
one,
of
how
McCartney
could
put
everything
he
had
into
a
song
–
except
a
proper
conclusion.
Thankfully,
the
first
half
of
this
is
so
perfect,
so
joyous
and
loved
filled,
that
it
carries
Wings
past
another
bad
end.

 


Album:


Wild
Life

(1971)


Most
played:
“Wild
Life”
(54
with
Wings;
1
solo)

Least
played:
“Love
Is
Strange”
(1
solo)

The
title
track
from


Wild
Life

helped
introduce
McCartney’s
new
band,
and
they
regularly
performed
this
song
in
concert.
At
least,
early
on.
The
LP
was
a
critical
bomb
and
McCartney
quickly
moved
on:
He
only
performed “Wild
Life”
one
more
time,
according
to
setlist.fm.
He’s
likewise
performed “Love
Is
Strange”
just
once.
In
fact,
the
most
played
track
from

Wild
Life

since
Wings
split
is
the

delicately
involving
“When
the
Wind
Is
Blowing.”
McCartney
has
returned
to
it
twice.

 


Album:


Ram

(1971)


Most
played:
“Ram
On”
(158
solo)

Least
played:
“3
Legs”
(1
solo)

McCartney
used “Ram
On”
as
a
recurring
motif
on


Ram
,
then
repurposed
its
closing
lines
– “who’s
that
coming
round
that
corner?
Who’s
that
coming
round
that
bend?
”
–
in
the
first
stanza
of “Big
Barn
Bed,”
the
opener
on
Wings’


Red
Rose
Speedway

in
1973.
(He’d
earlier
used
the
pseudonym
Paul
Ramon
to
remain
anonymous
on
an
early
Beatles
tour
and
as
a
sideman
with

Steve
Miller
.) “3
Legs”
was
inspired
by
a
drawing
of
a
friendly
canine
by
McCartney’s
daughter
Heather;
the
original
demo
had
been
titled “A
Dog
Is
Here
.”

 


Album:


McCartney

(1970)


Most
played:
“Maybe
I’m
Amazed”
(513
solo;
133
with
Wings)

Least
played:
“Junk”
and “The
Lovely
Linda”
(1
solo)

“Maybe
I’m
Amazed”
is
not
just
the
most
played
song
from
Paul
McCartney’s
first
proper
solo
album.
It’s
also
the
most
played
song
by
Wings,
the
group
he
formed
a
year
later
in
1971.
Their
live
version
resurrected
a
treasured
deep
cut
as “Maybe
I’m
Amazed”
became
a
Top
10
hit
following
its
release
on
1977’s


Wings
Over
America
. “Junk”
actually
dated
back
to
McCartney’s
days
with
the
Beatles,
though
the
song
never
moved
past
the

demo
phase
.

Paul
McCartney
Albums
Ranked

The
Beatles
always
defined
him,
but
McCartney’s
story
didn’t
end
there.

Gallery
Credit:

Nick
DeRiso


See
Paul
McCartney
in
Rock’s
Craziest
Conspiracy
Theories

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.